Home > Book Reviews

Book Review: The Book of Mormon Girl by Joanna Brooks

By Shelah Miner

Title: The Book of Mormon Girl: Stories from an American Faith

Author: Joanna Brooks

While Mitt Romney is undoubtedly the most high-profile Mormon in America right now, many might argue that Joanna Brooks is the most high-profile Mormon woman in America today. In addition to her job as chair of the English Department at San Diego State University, she writes for Religion Dispatches and Washington Post, hosts the Ask Mormon Girl website, and blogs at Feminist Mormon Housewives. Last week, the front page of CNN’s website included an in-depth story of Brooks and her family. So it’s really the perfect time for her memoir, The Book of Mormon Girl, to be released.

Brooks divides her life into three basic sections– growing up, early adulthood/disillusionment, and maturation/resolution. In the growing up years, which comprise the bulk of the memoir, she gives us detailed and delightful stories of her Young Women’s leaders and her grandmothers, interesting, devoted, hardworking women who taught her the gospel while hiking mountain passes and doing service. She writes about the cultural dissonance that comes from being “in the world but not of it.” She writes about her adoration for Marie Osmond. All of these chapters are rich with description and detail.

Joanna’s story is one that I’m familiar with because I’ve both heard her tell it and because I recognize parts of it in my friends and myself. Maybe not the growing up in the tract house on the edge of Southern California’s orange groves, but certainly the feeling of being the only LDS girl in my high school, of being a “root beer among cokes” as she puts it. Like Joanna, I was a girl who set my sights on attending BYU and only BYU, and when I arrived there and had to adjust when I realized that it wasn’t as perfect as I thought it would be. I see her story in the story of friends who have felt pain too acute to bear, pain they associate with the church, and have left as a result. And I see her story in friends who have come back from that pain, who want to find a way to live a life of integrity within the religion and culture in which they were raised.

Brooks’s adult chapters, as well as the way she has chosen to live her life publicly, do a lot to dispel the myth that Mormon women are all cut out of the same cloth, with the same thoughts and beliefs. She shows that it’s okay to grieve for the things we wish were different, that we can find our voice, even if we’re most comfortable speaking quietly and politely, and that we can love the church and want to be part of it without embracing every aspect of it. Furthermore, she shows that it’s possible, even fulfilling, to come back and to see raising children in a home where parents come from different faith traditions as a boon and a blessing.

Brooks chose to self-publish her memoir, and while I understand why she did it, and I really do think that she has both an important story to tell and the writing chops to carry it off with remarkable sensitivity and finesse, self-publishing is always a tricky business. The Book of Mormon Girl, is an engrossing and important memoir, but it’s not a perfect book. The child and teen chapters repeat many of the same details, and while the repetition seems to be intentional, the cumulative effect was to give sort of a storybook quality to the setting. Also, as a reader, I am interested in Brooks’s childhood, especially since her teen years seem to be such a reflection of mine, but I’m even more interested in how she went from belief to disillusionment and back again. She does give several chapters to the adult struggles in her life, but I want more. I think it’s a testament to the success of her writing both in The Book of Mormon Girl and in other venues, that we want more of Joanna’s wit and wisdom. And I’m confident that she’ll give it to us.

About Shelah Miner

(Co-Editor-in-Chief) teaches English at BYU and French at a Salt Lake City middle school. She has an addiction to her Audible account, hates making dinner, and embraces the chaos of life with a husband, six kids, a dog, a lizard and four rabbits.

8 thoughts on “Book Review: The Book of Mormon Girl by Joanna Brooks”

  1. Sounds worth a read but it seems from your review like the most important part, what her faith means to her now as an adult and how she got from A to B is missing.

    Something that bugs me off the bat is the title. As if she's grabbing the moniker as THE Book of Mormon girl, now unclaimable by anyone else. It smacks of self-importance and as if she's speaking for all of us.

  2. It's not missing, jendoop. I'm sorry if my review made it seem that way. But her youth is really covered in-depth, and they disaffection/return to faith is just a few chapters at the end. I know that's how memoirs work– there's often a focus on one particular story or part of the author's life, so maybe I'm asking too much here. While this child/youth story is really interesting, what I'm really intrigued by is the adult story. I guess that wanting more is a good thing, isn't it?

  3. Thanks, Shelah. Jendoop–yes, I know it's cheeky title. I thought about it a long time before swallowing and going for it. I certainly don't presume to speak for all Mormon women, and I do hope the generosity of the book's closing chapter–which tries to make a place for all of us in all of our diversity across our Mormon lives at the great table of Mormonism–makes up for the cheekiness. I always welcome feedback, and I have great admiration for the Segullah community. Thank you.

  4. Shelah,

    Nice review. Like you, I'm more interested in Joanna's adult life than her childhood and teen years.
    I have noticed that it's much easier for most people to write about their childhood. Writing about our adult lives, the paths we've chosen and where they'd led us requires more reflection and honesty than many of us can muster.

  5. I'm looking forward to reding Joanna's book for multiple reasons. I like memoirs, I am a Mormon girl who suffers the double consciousness this book apparently describes, and I grew up in the same ward as the author. Joanna's dad was my bishop. She's about 10 years younger than I am, so we didn't interact much. But I will probably have some flashbacks to our shared place. And I will certainly gain some insights into the identity issues I sometimes have about the way "Mormon" is one of the many adjectives (and one of the weigher ones) placed in front of the noun "girl" for me, too. Now I just have to kidnap my husband's kindle. He already downloaded Joanna's book. Thanks for the review!

  6. […] “Brooks dispels the myth that Mormon women are all cut out of the same cloth, with the same thoughts and beliefs. She shows that it’s okay to grieve for the things we wish were different, that we can find our voice, even if we’re most comfortable speaking quietly and politely, and that we can love the church and want to be part of it without embracing every aspect of it. The Book of Mormon Girl is an engrossing and important memoir.”–Shelah, Segullah […]


Leave a Comment